WWRW: Brede and Other Books

Linking up with Housewifespice for the March edition of What We’re Reading Wednesday!

I’ve read some great books since last month’s post. The best one was absolutely In This House of Brede by Rumer Godden, bredewhich seems to be having a moment around the Catholic blogosphere. I loved the style of the prose, the reported speech and the “If Sister X had heard this, she would have said”‘s. These little asides added a unique insight into the nuns’ interior lives without requiring a totally omniscient narrator. By exploring the nuns’ interior lives in this way, Godden also made the point that their enclosure does not make for a stagnant or automatically holy life; rather, their concerns, both prosaic and sacred, continue to school them in love. I liked that she didn’t make this point with ham-handed moralism, but let the story speak for itself.

I also loved all of the characters’ complexity. No character was all good or all bad. I thought Dame Veronica the least sympathetic character and her simpering devotion to the former Abbess the most annoying but she still showed a desire for repentance. I got rather attached to Philippa Talbot, the late vocation who leaves her high position in the Civil Service to join the convent. We open on her farewells to her employees:

Penny looked up and saw that Mrs Talbot was laughing at her, gently laughing. ‘Do you think it will be the end of me?’ Penny emphatically did but, ‘I hope it will be the beginning,’ said Mrs Talbot.

Screen Shot 2015-03-03 at 12.01.49 PM

From a lovely morning off

Her quiet transformation showed the many ways God teaches love. She was widowed already and then had lost a young son in a horrific accident (sobbing, so much sobbing), so she had had that experience of love but had reacted to losing her family by closing herself to everyone around her. After her conversion and even after entering the convent, she just wanted to keep to herself and work on her own holiness, but God uses the skills she developed for her own prosperity on the outside to serve the order over and over again, showing the unexpected way her vocation was both the beginning and end of her.

Abbess Catherine ended up a favorite as well. She exemplified what a mother is and what a mother should be. Her worry about the sisters, her occasional anger, but most of all care for the flock showed the joys and challenges of motherhood in the context of her vocation. There’s more to be said about motherhood and Brede, but I’ll leave that for another post.

Anyway, I think everyone should read it. It’s not sentimental or schlocky and really even-handed on the hot button political issues that come with a Catholic novel set during Vatican II.

Other books:

aramenI got to read an advance copy of Leah Libresco‘s new book Arriving at Amen: Seven Catholic Prayers Even I Can Offer and reviewed it on Goodreads. A taste of a particularly lovely passage:

In Confession, God mends to wound of my sin with his grace, and the resulting scar can be beautiful. The shining brand that remains is a gift; a reminder that I depend on God’s mercy, and that his mercy is free for the asking. This kind of healing means that I can’t think of my original sin in isolation from the forgiveness that was offered to me. The vein of Christ’s love twines through my regret and penitence, keeping them from sliding into despair.

If you liked Jennifer Fulweiler’s Something Other Than God, you’ll like Leah’s book too. You can pre-order it now on Amazon and I think you should!station eleven

Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel // Like Hansel, this is so hot right now and I think for good reason. I’m a sucker both for post-apocalyptic tales (my husband and I both get giddy about The Walking Dead) and for plots with characters with intersecting lives, which is why I love David Mitchell. My major complaint about the book is that I can’t decide if the ending was a cop-out or a reflection of the instability of an apocalyptic wasteland, but no spoilers here. Even so, it didn’t make me regret reading the rest of it.

excellentwomenExcellent Women by Barbara Pym // Fare Forward editor/Middlemarch-pusher, BD McClay, assigned this comedy of manners for her “Lenten homework” and I enjoyed it quite a bit. It epitomizes a particular British melancholic humor. I knew I would like the main character when she explains: “Let me hasten to add that I am not at all like Jane Eyre, who must have given hope to so many plain women who tell their stories in the first person, nor have I ever thought of myself as being like her” and then worries about the toilet paper situation sharing a bathroom with the couple who moves in downstairs. “Mr. Napier was called Rockingham! How the bearer of such a name would hate sharing a bathroom!”

I’m currently reading The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro, which started super slow, but I suppose that makes sense for the ruminations of an aging butler.

I’m also still working my way through Edith Stein’s letters in the mornings. I’ll finish off this post with this excerpt:

“I would like to break a lance for the angels. They do not stand like a barrier between us and God. The ray of illumination that (according to Dionysius) descends on us after having passed through all nine Choirs [of angels] connects the entire grace-inundated spirit world; the Trinity is personally present on every level; even in the lowest choir of angels it is he himself whom we meet. It is not his unapproachable majesty that God communicates to us through his messengers but rather his overflowing love. It is their bliss, just as it will be ours (and already is to some extent), to be allowed to cooperate in God’s dispensing of graces. Consider yourself fortunate indeed if these hunters have picked up your scent, and allow them to drive you into the arms of the Spirit of love and of truth.” (From Letter 267)

What have you been reading? Any recommendations? I love new Goodreads friends!


4 thoughts on “WWRW: Brede and Other Books

  1. Yes! Motherhood in Brede is totally something I’ve wanted to write about, too! And that Jane Eyre quote sold me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s